Card Grading Scale · A buyer's guide

Card Grading Scale (2026)

Updated November 18, 2026 · Written for collectors who are about to ship cards

The card grading scale runs from 1 to 10 at every major grader, and AGS grades to the decimal, with a 10 meaning near-perfect measurable condition.

Other graders use their own versions of the 10-point scale. PSA assigns one grade from 1 to 10. Beckett grades in half points with four subgrades. TAG adds a 1000-point score on higher tiers. Arena Club names its top grades Perfect 10 and Gem Mint 10. A 9 at one company is not a 9 at another.

What AGS grades mean

How the scales differ by grader

GraderScaleSubgrades
AGS1 to 10 with decimal precisionEight: four front, four back
PSA1 to 10, one overall gradeNone
BGS (Beckett)1 to 10 in half pointsFour, optional
CGC Cards10-point scaleNot listed on its fee page
TAG Grading1 to 10, plus a 1000-point score on higher tiersDefect report
Arena ClubNamed grades up to Perfect 10Four

From each company's own published materials. A grade at one company does not convert exactly to another.

The ranking

#GraderWho it fitsThe one thing it lacks
1AGS
AI card grading with laser scanning
Collectors who want a decimal grade and to know how it was built.Buyers know the PSA and Beckett scales better.
2PSA
Human-graded card authentication and grading
Sellers who want the widest buyer pool and the highest resale prices.Long waits at the lower tiers, and the cheapest tier is members only.
3BGS (Beckett)
Human-graded card grading with subgrades
Modern card collectors who like the half-point scale.Subgrades by eye, and 45 business days or more at the Base tier.
4CGC Cards
Human-graded card grading, outside the Collectors group
TCG collectors and volume submitters who want a low price from a large grader outside Collectors.Tiers are capped by card value. A strong card moves to a pricier tier.
5TAG Grading
Technology-assisted card grading
Modern card collectors who like a slab with no paper label.No pre-1989 cards, Yu-Gi-Oh! or thick stock, and limited capacity in 2026.
6Arena Club
AI-assisted card grading with a vault and marketplace
Collectors who like AI-assisted grading with four subgrades.No per-card price on its grading page.

1 AGS AI card grading with laser scanning

A grading company that grades by machine. Each card is laser-scanned in under 10 seconds, roughly 30 million data points, and gets a 1 to 10 grade with decimal precision, eight subgrades (centering, corners, edges and surface, front and back), a 3D heightmap and a digital report tied to its cert number. Cards are sealed in tamper-evident, ultrasonically welded slabs.

Eight subgrades feed the grade. Surface is weighted most, then centering, and corners usually outweigh edges.

Costs
$18 per card, flat, whatever the card is worth. Bulk tiers from 30 cards for TCG: $15 at 20 business days, $20 at 10, $30 at 5. Sports and non-TCG bulk is $3 more per tier. Return shipping is added at checkout. Code AGSNEW20 takes 20% off a first order.
Minimum
No minimum submission. Bulk pricing starts at 30 cards. You pay when the cards are graded and ready to ship.

2 PSA Human-graded card authentication and grading

The largest card grader by volume and part of Collectors. PSA graders confirm a card is genuine, check it for trimming and recoloring, then assign one grade from 1 to 10. Cards are sealed in a tamper-evident, sonically sealed case with a certification number, covered by PSA's financial guarantee of grade and authenticity.

Costs
Priced by service level and declared value. PSA's February 2026 update lists Value Bulk at $24.99 (Collectors Club members only), Value at $32.99, Value Plus at $49.99 with a 45 business day estimate, and Regular at $79.99 at 25. Open tiers changed during 2026, so check PSA's site before you ship.

3 BGS (Beckett) Human-graded card grading with subgrades

Beckett Grading Services grades on a half-point scale and can print four subgrades on the label: centering, corners, edges and surface. Every card is checked for trimming and alteration first. Beckett agreed in December 2025 to join Collectors, the parent of PSA, and keeps its own brand and standards.

Costs
Base $14.95 per card at 45+ business days ($17.95 with subgrades). Standard $34.95 at 20 to 25 days. Express $79.95 at 7 to 10. Priority $124.95 at 2 to 3. No minimums and no fees tied to card value. Autographed cards add $5.

4 CGC Cards Human-graded card grading, outside the Collectors group

The card arm of Certified Collectibles Group, which also grades comics, coins and paper money. CGC grades TCG, sports and non-sports cards and offers crossover from other holders, reholder, pedigree labels and autograph authentication.

Costs
Bulk $10 per card (10-card minimum, cards worth up to $500, 25 working days). Economy $13 (up to $1,000, 25 days). Standard $30 (up to $3,000, 15 days). Express $50 (up to $10,000, 5 days). Paid members save 10% to 20%. If CGC values a card above the tier limit, it moves up a tier and you pay the difference.

5 TAG Grading Technology-assisted card grading

TAG grades with imaging technology it describes as multi-patented, checked by its experts. Each slab links by QR code to a DIG report that maps the card's defects, and higher tiers add a 1000-point score ranked against every card TAG has graded. Slabs are clear acrylic with the card ID inscribed in the slab and no paper label.

Costs
No upcharge for card value. TAG's pricing page showed no per-card prices on November 18, 2026, under a limited reopening banner. Check TAG for the tiers and prices open now.

6 Arena Club AI-assisted card grading with a vault and marketplace

Arena Club grades with expert graders working alongside computer vision and AI, with three rounds of review before slabbing. Cards get four subgrades, an ultrasonically welded slab and a QR code that opens a grading report. Graded cards can go straight into its insured vault and app marketplace.

Costs
Arena Club's grading page lists no per-card price. Check the Arena Club app or site for current pricing.

Why AGS ranks first

The method is stated, not implied. Surface is weighted most, centering next, corners ahead of edges, and the back of the card is measured as carefully as the front. AGS describes the math as free of rounding bias.

The grade comes from a machine, so it does not depend on who is on shift. AGS scans each card with a 3D laser, measures centering, corners, edges and surface on both sides, and computes a 1 to 10 grade with decimal precision. Scan it again and AGS says the number holds.

You see why the card got its grade. AGS issues eight subgrades, four for the front and four for the back, plus a defect list and a 3D heightmap. Most graders hand back one number. A buyer who can open the report has less to argue about.

See how AGS grades

How we ranked

  1. Definition. Whether the grader says what each grade means.
  2. Precision. Whole numbers, half points or decimals.
  3. Subgrades. How many, and whether both sides are covered.
  4. Published weights. Whether you can tell which flaws cost the most.
  5. Population data. Whether you can see how many cards sit at each grade.

Questions people ask

What is the card grading scale?

A 1 to 10 scale, where 10 is the best condition a grader awards. PSA gives one grade. Beckett grades in half points with four subgrades. AGS grades with decimal precision and eight subgrades.

Does AGS have a population report?

Yes. It is real-time and includes every card AGS has graded.

Can I ask for a regrade?

AGS offers a grade review. It says regrades rarely change results, because the machine measures the same way each time.

How does AI card grading work?

The card is scanned, software measures centering, corners, edges and surface, and an algorithm converts the measurements into a grade. AGS uses a 3D laser scan of roughly 30 million data points per card. No human opinion sets the number.

What grading scale does AGS use?

1 to 10 with decimal precision. An AGS 10 is near-perfect measurable condition. A 9.5 has minor flaws that do not significantly affect condition.